Not all annodized aluminum is the same, here is a comparison of some ebay tags from china (right), and tags from chewbarka (left)
Note that I used the same power and speed for both, and it is possible I would need to dial in the settings for the ebay tags to get better results.
The ebay tags were $6.00 usd / 20, and chewbarka tags are $1.00 each, though the ones I purchased were in an bulk assortment of $25/pound. The chewbarka tags were also thicker, and had a smoother texture to them.